Pros of Blue Light-Blocking Filters:


1. Reduced Eye Strain: Extended screen time can lead to digital eye strain, causing symptoms like dry eyes, fatigue, and blurred vision. Blue light-blocking filters may help alleviate these symptoms by reducing the amount of high-energy blue light that reaches your eyes, resulting in reduced eye strain and discomfort.  Other methods to reduce eye strain include taking breaks, adjusting your screen settings, using glare filters on your screen, and using artificial tears.  


2. Improved Sleep Quality: Exposure to blue light, especially in the evening, can interfere with our natural sleep-wake cycle by suppressing the production of melatonin, a hormone that regulates sleep. Blue light-blocking filters can help limit the amount of blue light reaching your eyes, potentially improving your sleep quality and promoting a more restful night.  We get far more blue light exposure from sunlight than we do from screens.  Blue light exposure from the sun is helpful for maintaining our circadian rhythm, and time outdoors is a healthy part of it (do wear sunglasses outdoors to block harmful UVA/UVB rays.  You'll still get the beneficial effects!).  Another option to limit the potential impact of blue light on sleep issues is to simply limit screen time to 1-2 hours prior to sleep.


3. Potential Protection from Macular Degeneration: Some studies suggest that long-term exposure to blue light may contribute to the development of age-related macular degeneration (AMD), a leading cause of vision loss. Blue light-blocking filters may offer an added layer of protection by reducing the amount of blue light entering the eye, potentially decreasing the risk of AMD.  However, we will get far more blue light exposure from sunlight than we will from screens, and most retina specialists do not routinely recommend blue-light filtering lenses as a form of macular degeneration protection.


4. Minimal Color Distortion: Modern blue light-blocking filters are designed to selectively filter out blue light while maintaining color accuracy. This means that you can enjoy the benefits of blue light reduction without significant color distortion, ensuring a natural viewing experience. 


Cons of Blue Light-Blocking Filters:


1. Limited Scientific Evidence: While there is some evidence to suggest that blue light can have negative effects on eye health and sleep, the scientific consensus on the efficacy of blue light-blocking filters is still evolving. Some studies have shown benefits, while others have found little to no difference in outcomes. More research is needed to establish the long-term effects and efficacy of these filters.


2. Potential Disruption of Sleep-Wake Cycle: While blue light-blocking filters can be beneficial for reducing blue light exposure in the evening, using them during the day may interfere with your natural circadian rhythm. Daytime exposure to blue light is essential for alertness and maintaining a healthy sleep-wake cycle. Excessive filtering of blue light during the day may lead to daytime sleepiness and disruption of normal biological processes.


3. False Sense of Security: Blue light-blocking filters should not be viewed as a complete solution to all screen-related issues. They may provide some benefits, but they do not address other factors contributing to eye strain, such as poor posture, improper lighting, or excessive screen time. Relying solely on blue light filters may lead to neglecting other essential measures for maintaining eye health.


4. Potential Color Distortion: While modern blue light filters aim to preserve color accuracy, some users may still experience slight color distortion or a yellowish tint. This effect can be more pronounced in lower-quality filters. 


The bottom line:  There is not clear evidence that blue-light blocking lenses provide a significant benefit.  If you spend long hours on screens, it is unlikely that using blue light lenses would be harmful and some patients swear by the improvement they feel.  But the scientific jury is still out on whether the potential benefits of these lenses live up to the hype.
 

Written by  Tyler Nelson, OD
 

Give us a call to schedule an appointment with Dr. Nelson at Arbor Eyecare


Dr. Tyler Nelson